Paper 23: http://www.ch.ic.ac.uk/ectoc/papers/sweeney/

Dr J M Goodman (jmg11@cam.ac.uk)
Mon, 19 Jun 1995 15:16:53 +0000

Dear Joe,

I am very interested by your hydroxyselenation poster, and particularly by
your challenge to explain the results. I think it is possible to explain
the results without needing to assume two rather different reactions go at
the same speed.

Your first mechanism suggests that an intermediate is formed, which may
lead to two products:

[figure1]

It may be that the reaction goes just by a mechanism of the second type.
When the acetate is axial, it withdraws electrons from the double bond, and
so deactivates it. If the acetate is equatorial, it is orthogonal to the
double bond, and so no longer deactivates it. However, it need have no
other effect.

[figure2]

It is unlikely that two different reactions will go at the same rate under
all conditions of temperature and solvent. The mechanism I suggest can be
shown to be wrong, by repeating the experiment with different solvents and
temperatures. My mechanism suggests that the ratio should always be 1:1.
The mechanism in the poster would probably suggest that the ratio should
vary with solvent and temperature. The idea could also be tested by doing
the reaction on fluorocyclohexene. The fluoride should have a similar
electronic effect to the acetate, deactivating the axial conformation, but
would not be able to deliver the selenium, as in the mechanism of the
poster. It should, therefore, also give a 1:1 mixture.

I have attached to schemes to this message as tgf files. This message can
also be read in full on http://www.ch.cam.ac.uk/MMRG/ECTOC/sweeney.html

Yours sincerely,

Jonathan Goodman


Dr J M Goodman Email:jmg11@cam.ac.uk Telephone:01223 336434
FAX: 01223 336362 Secretary (Mrs Hudson): 01223 336342
Department of Chemistry, Lensfield Road, Cambridge, CB2 1EW
World Wide Web: http://www.ch.cam.ac.uk/CUCL/org/jmg.html

(This file must be converted with BinHex 4.0)

:#fCTCh9bC6%ZG'GQ!'e84dC(E@4X!!!!!#)U!!!!!-%8$54@CA*cD@pZ1L!c)!d
N9'pdEf*UFcSJ0MJJ$543C@jI8NG#-N0[E'pb1L!`)$!J-#!0*%CTE'aI8NG#-N0
[E'pb1L!`)$!J-#!0*%C[ER3k)#*(C@jPGQ%L)$%b-#!`)!d0*%pLDMSJE@pX)!d
N8RKZ3A4MD$SJ,6%J,6%J$3dN6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j"G'0S1L!Y-5!Y-5!0*%*
PCh0VCA4MD$SJ$548Eh4[BQTc1L!b05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*
NFcSJ-6-a-5i`-$!`-#!a16Bc,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcSJ)P0P8'JL)!d
N3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*
[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$!J-L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6-a-#i
b0cBd0L!b-63b,M-c-6Fc)!dN3A4[E9pdHA"P1L!h)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%
c)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a-68e,M!i0M-b)$)b-c!Z16J
c0MBJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-63J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-
k)$%d0$)Z063h1$8J-M)f-Lie-M)d-b!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!a0b!0$542BQS
k)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!b)$-J$54#EfjNAh4
[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'p
YFcSJ-b!a-#!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfP
NG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!j)$3J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*
U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ0#!b)!dN3QpZC&p
dEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a-cBj,M%`-63
d)$)d-M8Z0$8b-M%J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-6BJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4
[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%a16%Z0$3f0M)J-M3`05ij1$-j1#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!
a05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6!i05ih06Nb-b!b068`,M%
`-c-j)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%i)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4
c1L!a-68h,MFb0MBh)$)h-6-Z0MNa-$3J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-6NJ$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%c-c8Z-cJa0$JJ-MFc-bia06Nb0b!0*%&
dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b-#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-63d-5i
`0MJi0L!b06Jj,M!c16Jf)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)a)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!
0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$NJ-6!J$54#EfjNAh4jF'8k)'4
[G@*XC5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJBA*[E5!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'J
k)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a-#!a-5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJBA*[E5!0$542BQS
k)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a-5!a-L!0*%*[EQ4
IG(P`C6SJC'peBQaP)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"KFQpY)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"
PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%b)$%c)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"KFQp
Y)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%c)$%
d)!dN3QpZC&pdHA"P1L"NEh9LE'8J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)'&bEfdJ$3dN6f*U1L"
LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-63J15!0*%*[EQ4IG'p
`EcSJBA*[E5!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ16N`,MNi068h)$)
a06FZ-$%h1$%J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M)J$3dN6f*
U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-b!b-5!0*%*[EQ4
IG(P`C6SJC'peBQaP)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a0M%i,MF
i0$)a)$)b-M8Z16!f-M-J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M-
J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ0#!b-b!
0*%*[EQ4IG(P`C6SJC'peBQaP)!dN4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!d
N3A*bEhG%DA)k)$%J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M)j05!
a1$Jh)$)f-$)J-6Ji0b!0$542BQSk)'e[E#!0*&*iEN&dBfJk)#da)#da)!dN3Q9
RFfYPG'0S1L!0*&4[G'pLDR-k)$)c)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4
c1L!c-$J`,M!`-$!`)$%i1$)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M3J$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-`1$!Z-$!`-$!J-M!f-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&
dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c)c05i
i1$3e-L!b-68b,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)f)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!
0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c-cNa,MFf16!d)$)`0M)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*
PFMSJ-MFJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-c16%Z0cBj-$3J-6J
i-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b1#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0
[Eh*NFcSJ-c)c05ii1$3e-L!a0cNb,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)j)!d
0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$!J-5!0*%*
[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#Efj
NAf&dEfec1L!a)$)J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9
ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-L!c)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d
0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-J0#!0*%*
[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#Efj
NAf&dEfec1L!d)$8J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9
ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ05!`)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d
0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c-M-e,MJi0$8a)$%f-6)Z-$!`-$!
J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c!J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!d
N8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ05!a-L!0*%*[EQ4IFh4PFQ9[Ah4
jF'8k)(9`)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c063h,MBe-cBa)$%
h16)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAf&XD@&c1L!L6bXL)!dN3A4
[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-a)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4
IBA4[EA-k)$3J-63J$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"P1L"eF#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfd
J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c8d0bif06-f-5!b-68a,MNj16Ni)!dN3A4[E9pKE'P
KFcSJ)P0P8'JL)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPp
hD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-J-6BJ$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"P1L"
NEhGZ)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c0$!i,M!`-$!`)$%e0M8
Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c-J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4
S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6)J-6JJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4
S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-63J-6JJ$54#EfjNAh4jF'8k)'4[G@*XC5!0$54
2BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c3h0#ia063d-#!a-cNh,M8j0c8`)!d
N3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-d)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*
[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%i)$)a)!dN4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!dN3A*
bEhG%DA)k)$%J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c%j15!b0M%
b)$-`16JJ-MN`-L!0$542BQSk)'aTEQ8J$54"FR*[Gd4TFMSJ-5!0*%&bFQph8h4
jE'8k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4c1L!c0cFj)$)f-6)J-cJi-#!b16!b)!d0*%pLDMS
JE@pX)!dN8RKZ3A4MD$SJ,6%J,6%J$3dN6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j"G'0S1L!Y-5!
Y-5!0$542BQSk)'&bBb!0*%&bFQph4'Pb1L!a)!dN3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!0*%p
LDPpMEfpbC(-k)$%b16%J-6!i-L!a0M8h)$%d-c-J$54"FQ0IC@jNF(4c1L!a06-
c)$%`16-J-6-c-L!a-cBc)!d0*%pLDMSJBA*M)!dN3A*bEhG%DA)k)$)J$54"FR*
[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c3d-#!a-M!`)$-i-MBJ-68i0L!0*%&
bBepPEQ4`G(-k)$-e-M8J-68d05!c1$!j)$%d-c8J$3dN6f*U1L"dCAKd)!dN9(*
KER0`BA*PER3k)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-cBd-#!a-MFa)$-j-6!J-68e-5!0*%e
%6%9NDA4dCAKd1L!a)$!`-6%J$AYFFR4Q-9aNC@CQEh*YBA4FE@&M)!elA'C[ER4
dBQ`J$5!J)(YFCM0FEQPX)%GPEQ9fB6Yp$Ad0A'BcA'Cc-M3J5!eFF'aKD@iJ$9a
Q-eaQFc)d)&aNEMBJ-JeFF'aKD@iJ$9aQ-eaQFc)d)%m0A("XB@PZ)!ep$3d0*%p
LDMSJBA*M)!dN3A*bEhG%DA)k)$)J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*
NFcSJ-6!`-5!a0$Nc)$%c1$FJ-6Jh15!0*%&bBepPEQ4`G(-k)$%c063J-6Fh-5!
a-c)c)$%e06!J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!f)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-
k)$-i0c!Z-$!`-$!J-c3c-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0#!0$542BQS
k)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$BJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-cJh-#i`-$!`-#!c0M%
c,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)e)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$S
J0L!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!d-$)e,MJi0$8b)$-h-$-Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfj
eE@*PFMSJ-MBJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!f)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-
k)$3a1$%Z0cBj-$3J-cBa-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0b!0$542BQS
k)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$BJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ0$%i-5ih0MN`0#!c0$-
c,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)i)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$S
J0L!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!d-$)e,MJi0$8b)$-c0$-Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfj
eE@*PFMSJ-MNJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'p
YFcSJ-6)J-6-J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhG
TC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6-J-63J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3d
N6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-63J-68J$54
#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3Qp
ZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-68J-6BJ$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!d
N8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6BJ-6FJ$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*
TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6F
J-6)J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!f)!d
N3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$3`-M8Z1$Jd06%J-c%f-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIG(P`C6S
J1#!0*%&dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*23@-L)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-`)!d0*%pLDMS
JBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%h)$)d)!dN3QpZC&p
cG'9bC@pIG(P`C6SJGA!J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!f)!dN3A4[E9p
MEfpbC(-k)$3c-cFZ0M8c0M%J-c-d-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIG(P`C6SJ1#!0*%&
dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*25#)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c%J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!d
N8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6BJ-MBJ$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEep
dHA"P1L"eF#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$BJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcS
J0$-c0bif06-f-5!c0c!b,MNj16Ni)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcSJ)P0P8'JL)!dN3A4
[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4
IBA4[EA-k)$%e)$)i)!dN3QpZC&pcG'9bC@pIG(P`C6SJC'phEL!0$542BQSk)'&
dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$!J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6)f-5i`-$!`-#!a0$8c,M!
`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!`)!d
N3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%d0$%Z-$!`-$!J-63e-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9
b1L!b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-
`)$-a)!dN3QpZC&pdHA"P1L"NEh9LE'8J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!`)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%f-M%Z-$!`-$!J-63
e-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!c)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4
dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-a)$-c)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%p
LDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-#!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a-$Ja,M!`-$!`)$%
d06-Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfP
NG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!c-#!c05!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$54
2BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$!J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6)`1#i`-$!`-#!
a06Ja,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$8J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhG
TC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-c8J-cFJ$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3d
N6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!`)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%d16-Z-$!`-$!
J-6-b0Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!f)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPp
hD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-c)$-j)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d
0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-h)$-j)!d
N3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-#!0*%&dEfe
IBfp[FQ4c1L!a0cFf,M!`-$!`)$%c0M)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54
"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0b!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#Efj
NAf&dEfec1L!c-b!d-L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$!J$54"G'pYAf0
[Eh*NFcSJ-6Fh0#if1$Nh0b!a-6Jb,M!`0$Ff)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$NJ$3d
N6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ0$)J0$3J$3d
N6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!`)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%j-MNZ-$!`-$!
J-6!j-5i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!a-#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@j
IGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!d0#!d0L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*
PER3k)$!J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6Ba1#i`0MBf05!a-$Nc,M)j0M)c)!dN3A4
[E9pdHA"P1L!i)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%a)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPp
hD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$3d)$3i)!dN3QpZC&pdHA"P1L"NEh9LE'8
J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!h)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)e1$!Z-$!
`-$!J-c3c-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54
3BA*PER3k)$FJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M8i-#i`-$!`-#!c0M%b,M!`-$!`)!d
N3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)e)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ0b!0*%&dEfe
IBfp[FQ4c1L!b0c-e,MJi0$8b)$-h-$)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-MB
J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!h)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)i16%Z0cB
j-$3J-cBa-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0b!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54
3BA*PER3k)$FJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-MJj-5ih0MN`0#!c0$-b,M!`-$!`)!d
N3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)i)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ0b!0*%&dEfe
IBfp[FQ4c1L!b0c-e,MJi0$8b)$-c0$)Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-MN
J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ06!J06%
J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!d
N3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ06%J06)J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfj
N)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ06)J06-J$54#EfjNAh4[F'm
k)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcS
J06-J063J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4
S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ063J068J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*
U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ068J06!J$54#Efj
NAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!h)!dN3A4[E9pMEfp
bC(-k)$)h-c8Z1$Jd06%J-c%f-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIG(P`C6SJ1#!0*%&dEfe
IB@aTBA-k)#*25#)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c!J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9
ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ068J0M)J$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"
P1L"eF#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$FJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c!
d0bif06-f-5!c-c3b,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pdHA"P1L!i)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcS
J)Np"Bb)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c%J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4
S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ063J0M3J$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"P1L"eF#!
0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$FJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c!d0bif06-
f-5!c0c!a,MNj16Ni)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcSJ)P0P8'JL)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)
k)$-b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$8
c)$Bf)!dN3QpZC&pcG'9bC@pIG(P`C6SJC'phEL!0*%9ZC(0VCA4MD$SJ$G@2!!!
!:

(This file must be converted with BinHex 4.0)

:#fCTCh9bC6)ZG'GQ!'e84dC(E@4X!!!!!#PE!!!"(LbU$54@CA*cD@pZ1L!c)!d
N9'pdEf*UFcSJ0c!J$543C@jI8NG#-N0[E'pb1L!`)$!J-#!0*%CTE'aI8NG#-N0
[E'pb1L!`)$!J-#!0*%C[ER3k)#*(C@jPGQ%L)$%b-#!`)!d0*%pLDMSJE@pX)!d
N8RKZ3A4MD$SJ,6%J,6%J$54#C@GcDf9dBfJk)!dN9'pdEf*UFcSJ-M!J$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)b16BZ-$!`-$!J-68c0bi`-$!`-#!0*%&
dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!a)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!b0$Ff,M!
`-$!`)$%e-cFZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$54
3C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!`)$%J$54#EfjNAh4jF'8k)'4[G@*
XC5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcS
J-MBe0Li`-$!`-#!a06-h,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-J$3dN6f*U1L"
LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-5!c)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"
[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!b-6%f,M!`-$!`)$%
e-cFZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfP
NG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!`)$8J$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*TEQFJ$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)b0$-Z-$!`-$!J-6Bf05i`-$!`-#!0*%&
dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!e)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4
IBA4[EA-k)$8J0b!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'p
YAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M8b1#i`-$!`-#!a0$%`,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$B
J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-b!j)!d
N3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*
[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$FJ15!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54
"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-MJa-5i`-$!`-#!a0$3f,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pdHA"P1L!
i)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$FJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!d
N3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-b!a-L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-MN
f0bie-c8f0#!a06-d,MJf-MNb)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)a)!d0*%pLDMSJBQp
ZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%b)$%d)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4
[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!b16Bi,MJd06F`)$%h-63Z1$8i-68J$54"G'pYAfj
eE@*PFMSJ-M)J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'p
YFcSJ-63J-6BJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-a-M)Z0cB`16N
J-63d-bih-c!h-5!0*%&dEfeIG(P`C6SJ1#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b-b!0$54
2BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a0#!a1#!0*%*
[EQ4IG(P`C6SJC'peBQaP)!dN4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j
"G'0S1L!Y-5!Y-5!0$542BQSk)(0eBR0VCA4MD#!0*%*PCh0VCA4MD$SJ$548Eh4
[BQTc1L!c)!d0*%pLDMSJE'PZC5!0*%&bFQph8h4jE'8k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4
c1L!a0$)h)$%e-6!J-6J`-L!a06%a)!d0*%pLDMSJE'PZC5!0*%&bFQph8h4jE'8
k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4c1L!a0$N`)$%e0$8J-63b-b!a06!i)!d0*%pLDMSJFh9
LFfYPG'0S)!dN3Q9RFfYPG'0S1L!0*&4[G'pLDR-k)$)J$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!d
N3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$%d-M-J-63f-#!a1$!b)$%d0M%
J$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!dN3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$%i-$)
J-63f-5!a0c-e)$%d-M3J$54&EQ4cDf9dBfJk)!d0*%9ZC(0VCA4MD$SJ$3d0*%p
LDMSJG'9iG#!0*&4bB@jcF'&bC@jd1L!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$)b-#!j16%J16%
`)$%a0c%J$5404%a&C'PdG'9iG$SJ-5!`-$%a)!elA(*dCM&FC'9QCQpbE@&dA'e
KBb!0HeaQEfjdG'*X)!dJ)#"lA'BcA'jTE#"(C@jPGQ%lI3ep$9aQ-eaQFc)d)(9
ZFQ9KBh4TGQ80A("XB@PZ)!ep$3d0*%pLDMSJG'9iG#!0*&4bB@jcF'&bC@jd1L!
0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$)a1$!J-6!`-5!b0c-`)$%a1$%J$5404%a&C'PdG'9iG$S
J-5!`-$%a)!elA(*dCM&FC'9QCQpbE@&dA'eKBb!0HeaQEfjdG'*X)!dJ)#"lA'B
cA'jTE#"(C@jPGQ%lI3ep$9aQ-eaQFc)d)(*PB@0dDACP$9a`E'&TEL!0I3d0$54
2BQSk)(0eBR0VCA4MD#!0*%*PCh0VCA4MD$SJ$548Eh4[BQTc1L!c)!d0*%pLDMS
JE'PZC5!0*%&bFQph8h4jE'8k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4c1L!b-cJa)$%j0$NJ-M%
i-L!b-MBh)!d0*%pLDMSJE'PZC5!0*%&bFQph8h4jE'8k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4
c1L!b-c%i)$%j1$3J-M-i05!a163h)!d0*%pLDMSJFh9LFfYPG'0S)!dN3Q9RFfY
PG'0S1L!0*&4[G'pLDR-k)$)J$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!dN3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!
0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$)d-MBJ-6Nh-L!b-M)d)$)b16-J$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!d
N3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$)b-M3J-M)j-b!b-MNa)$)b06B
J$54&EQ4cDf9dBfJk)!d0*%9ZC(0VCA4MD$SJ$3d0*%pLDMSJFh9LFfYPG'0S)!d
N3Q9RFfYPG'0S1L!0*&4[G'pLDR-k)$-J$3dN6f*U1L"XD@jP)!dN3A*bEhG6G(P
XC6SJ-5!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$-a-$FJ-6Nd15!c-c!f)$)b0MFJ$3dN6f*U1L"
XD@jP)!dN3A*bEhG6G(PXC6SJ-5!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$-a0c!J-6Ni0#!c-6!
c)$%j0$FJ$3dN6f*U1L"cG@*cDf9dBfJJ$54#C@GcDf9dBfJk)!dN9'pdEf*UFcS
J-L!0$542BQSk)'aTEQ8J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c!
f-L!a16Fb)$-b0M3J-M)j-b!0$542BQSk)'aTEQ8J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!d
N6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c)f0#!b-MNc)$-a16FJ-M)e0L!0*%9ZC(0VCA4MD$SJ$3d
N4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j"G'0S1L!Y-5!Y-5!0*%*PCh0
VCA4MD$SJ$548Eh4[BQTc1L!b-L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcS
J-6Bj0Li`-$!`-#!b0cNi,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%J$3dN6f*U1L"
KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%i0cBZ-$!`-$!J-MFj1#i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfe
IER9YBQ9b1L!b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4
[EA-k)$!J-5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0
[Eh*NFcSJ-M!e0Li`-$!`-#!b0cNi,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-J$3d
N6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-5!c)!d0*%p
LDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a06%f,M!`-$!`)$)h16JZ-$!`-$!J$54
"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#Efj
NAf&dEfec1L!`)$8J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%f0$-Z-$!
`-$!J-MNb0Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!e)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"
PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$8J0b!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'p
YAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6Nb1#i`-$!`-#!b0MFa,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$B
J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-b!j)!d
0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!b-M%a,M!`-$!`)$)h-$FZ-$!`-$!
J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0b!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$54
3C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!c)$%a)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&
dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!b-cBh,M8c06Bd)$)h168Z1$Bc-$3J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMS
J-M%J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6%
J-6-J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)c0MJZ1$3e0c!J-MNh05i
i06Ja05!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b-L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'J
k)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a-b!a05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*
NFcSJ-M8b-Lih0M!j15!b0c!d,MFc-$Fa)!dN3A4[E9pdHA"P1L!i)!dN3A4[E9p
ZG@eLCA)k)$)c)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4
[EA-k)$%c)$%h)!dN3QpZC&pdHA"P1L"NEh9LE'8J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4
[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%h16!Z-$!`-$!J-M3h-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*
6C5Y3D#)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M3J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4
S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-5!a15!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQS
k)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!`)$%j)!dN3QpZC&p
dEh"[1L"bD@jR)!dN4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j"G'0S1L!
Y-5!Y-5!0*%*PCh0VCA4MD$SJ$548Eh4[BQTc1L!b-L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$54
"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c)h0Li`-$!`-#!b0cBi,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)
k)$%J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-d06BZ-$!`-$!J-MFf1#i
`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$S
J0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$!J-5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&
dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-cBc0Li`-$!`-#!b0cBi,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9p
ZG@eLCA)k)$-J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'p
YFcSJ-5!c)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c-$Nf,M!`-$!`)$)
h0MJZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfP
NG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!`)$8J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfp
bC(-k)$-b-M-Z-$!`-$!J-MJj0Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!e)!d0*%p
LDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$8J0b!0$542BQS
k)'&dEfdJ$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-c8`1#i`-$!`-#!b0M3a,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4
[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$BJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&p
KG'pYFcSJ-b!j)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c0cNa,M!`-$!
`)$)f0cFZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ0b!0$54
2BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!c)$%a)!d0*%p
LDMSJBA4[E5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c163h,M8c06Bd)$)h0M8Z1$Bc-$3J$54
"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M%J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3Qp
ZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6%J-6-J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-j0$J
Z1$3e0c!J-MNd05ii06Ja05!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b-L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3
J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a-b!a05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfd
J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ0$%`-Lih0M!h0#!b0MFd,MFc-$Fa)!dN3A4[E9pdHA"
P1L!i)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)c)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$S
J0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%c)$%h)!dN3QpZC&pdHA"P1L"NEh9LE'8J$3dN6f*
U1L"KG'pY)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-c1$!Z-$!`-$!J-c%j-bi`-$!`-#!0*%&
dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*6C5Y3D#)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M8J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfj
N)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-#!a15!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcS
JFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!
a15!a)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!dN4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0$3dN6f*U1L"XD@j
P)!dN3A*bEhG%DA)k)$%J$54"FR*[Ge0dH@aP1L!a)!dN6f*UAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M!
d0#!c-cFa)$)`0$3J-cBh1#!0$542BQSk)'aTEQ8J$54"FR*[Gd4TFMSJ-5!0*%&
bFQph8h4jE'8k)$%J$542BQTIBfp[FQ4c1L!c0$%d)$-c0c%J-c3a0#!c0MFi)!d
0*%pLDMSJG'9iG#!0*&4bB@jcF'&bC@jd1L!0*%pLDPpMEfpbC(-k)$)c-M!J-c-
d0#!c-68`)$-f1$3J$5404%a&C'PdG'9iG$SJ-5!`-$%a)!elA(*dCM&FC'9QCQp
bE@&dA'eKBb!0HeaQEfjdG'*X)!dJ)#"lA'BcA'jTE#"(C@jPGQ%lI3ep$9aQ-ea
QFc)d)(4bB@jc)'4TBAKTB@aFF'&b$A*TEQFJEh"PEQPZC`eFF'aKD@iJ$Ad0$3d
N6f*U1L"YEf`J$545H'j"G'0S1L!Y-5!Y-5!0$542BQSk)'e[E#!0*&*iEN&dBfJ
k)#da)#da)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcS
J-6N`0bi`-$!`-#!d-c!d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)d)!d0*%pLDMS
JBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6N`0bi`-$!`-#!d0$J
d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)e)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$S
J-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M!f-Lii1$3e-L!d06Fd,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9p
ZG@eLCA)k)$)f)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*
NFcSJ-M)a1#ih0MN`0#!d0$Jd,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)h)!d0*%p
LDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M)a1#ih0MN`0#!
d-c!d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)i)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9
ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M!f-Lii1$3e-L!d-M%d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4
[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$)j)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4
IBA4[EA-k)$%d)$%e)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"
PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%e)$%f)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@j
R)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%f)$%
h)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!
0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%h)$%i)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBQp
ZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$%i)$%j)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"
[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-
k)$%j)$%d)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$S
J-6-J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M!f-Lii1$3e-L!d-$-d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9p
dHA"P1L!i)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcSJ)Np"Bb)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c!J$3d
N6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-6NJ-MBJ$54
#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"P1L"eF#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%c)!d
N3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$)c0c3Z0M8c1$%J0$)a0#i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIG(P`C6S
J1#!0*%&dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*6C9"S)L!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!c-5!0$542BQS
k)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a1#!b1#!0*%*[EQ4
IFh4PFQ9[Ah4jF'8k)(9`)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-6-J$54"G'p
YAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-M-h0#if06-i-5!d06Fd,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pKE'PKFcSJ)Np
))L!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!c-L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$F
J$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!a0b!c-#!0*%*[EQ4IFh4PFQ9[Ah4jF'8k)'4[GfiJ$3d
N6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!a)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$8j0bi`-$!`-#!
a0$Ne,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%a)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9
ZG$SJ-5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!h0cFZ-$!`-$!J-63j05i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfe
IER9YBQ9b1L!a-L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&
dEfec1L!c-L!c-b!0*%*[EQ4IG(P`C6SJC'peBQaP)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"bD@j
R)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!j06FZ-$!
`-$!J-63j05i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!a-b!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$54
3C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!c-b!c05!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQP
ZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ0$%h,M!
`-$!`)$%d168Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-63J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!d
N8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-c)J-cFJ$54#EfjNAh4[F'mk)(*
TEQFJ$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!a)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$8d0#i
`-$!`-#!a-cBh,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%e)!d0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!
0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$-h)$-j)!dN3QpZC&pdEh"[1L"
bD@jR)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!i-MN
Z-$!`-$!J-6Bb-Li`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!a0L!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3
J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!c05!d-5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcS
JFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!
c15!d-5!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%
J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ168h,M!`-$!`)$%c-68Z-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8
k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-6FJ$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!
h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ-c8J0$3J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!a)!d
N3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$%a-6)Z-$!`-$!J-6)b0#i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9
b1L!a1#!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!
d0#!d0L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%J$54"G'pYAf0[Eh*NFcSJ-6)
f0bi`-$!`-#!a-c%d,M!`-$!`)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$%j)!d0*%pLDMSJBQp
ZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$3f)$3i)!d0*%pLDMSJBA4
[E5!0*&"KFQ9ZG$SJ-5!0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!a-6%a,M8f0c!b)$%`0$3Z-$!
`0$NJ$54"G'pYAh4jF'8k)$JJ$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-M!J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfj
N)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ0$BJ06!J$54#EfjNAh4jF'8
k)'4[G@*XC5!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-
k)$-b0cBZ-$!`-$!J0$)i15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0#!0$542BQS
k)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-b0cBZ-$!`-$!J0$3
f15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b05!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3
k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-d-c%Z1$Jd06)J0$8e15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfe
IER9YBQ9b1L!b0L!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfp
bC(-k)$-e1$FZ0cBj-$3J0$3f15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b0b!0$54
2BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-e1$FZ0cBj-$3
J0$)i15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b1#!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*
PER3k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-d-c%Z1$Jd06)J0$%j15i`-$!`-#!0*%&
dEfeIER9YBQ9b1L!b15!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#Efj
NAf&dEfec1L!e-L!e-b!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$54
3C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!e-b!e0#!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQP
ZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!e0#!
e05!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$F
J$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!e05!e0L!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*
[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfec1L!e0L!e0b!0*%*[EQ4IG'p
`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'*[EQ3J$543C@jIGfPNG'Jk)$FJ$54#EfjNAf&dEfe
c1L!e0b!e-L!0*%*[EQ4IG'p`EcSJFQPZCb!0$542BQSk)'&dEfdJ$543BA*PER3
k)$%b)!dN3A4[E9pMEfpbC(-k)$-d-c%Z1$Jd06)J0$!a15i`-$!`-#!0*%&dEfe
IG(P`C6SJ1#!0*%&dEfeIB@aTBA-k)#*23@-L)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-`)!d
0*%pLDMSJBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$8h)$Bd)!d
N3QpZC&pcG'9bC@pIG(P`C6SJGA!J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!a-L!
0*%&dEfeIBfp[FQ4c1L!c0c3c,MBe-cJa)$3a16NZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAh4jF'8
k)$JJ$54"G'pYAf&XD@&c1L!L6dJL)!dN3A4[E9pZG@eLCA)k)$-a)!d0*%pLDMS
JBQpZC#!0*&"PEPphD@4dD$SJ0b!0*%*[EQ4IBA4[EA-k)$8f)$Bf)!dN3QpZC&p
cG'9bC@pIG(P`C6SJGA!J$3dN6f*U1L"KG'pY)!dN8'&bC@jd1L!a-L!0*%&dEfe
IBfp[FQ4c1L!c0c3c,MBe-cJa)$3e06NZ-$!`-$!J$54"G'pYAf&XD@&c1L!L8f9
3D#)J$54"G'pYAfjeE@*PFMSJ-c)J$3dN6f*U1L"LEfjN)!dN8'9ZAhGTC(4S1L!
h)!dN3QpZC&pKG'pYFcSJ068J0MJJ$54#EfjNAh0dCA*PEepdHA"P1L"NEhGZ)!d
N4@jNFfYPG'0S1L!0VD`!!!%!!!!"!!!!!!!!!!!HE60%UJ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!3!!"%d,CQPRGA*P-LjdCfB#!!)!E94(4NGYC'`!!!"3!5!!!!)
!E94(4NGYC'`!!!"3!5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#X#c8M!!!T@`!!!4i!!!!
!!!%!!$5GUj!!d&S-8Ne1)#KZEb!i1$%T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%
!!$FUUj4eA"*0B@0TER4[FfJJ8fpQG(GKFQ8!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!3!!"%f
VPL01&%jPG(G[FQXJ4@&cH5"*ER0dB@aX!!!!!!!!!!!!!3!!!!%!!!!!!!!!!"i
!!!!!!!!!!!!F!"lrrf1N:


ECTOC-1. Conference home page: http://www.ch.ic.ac.uk/ectoc/ using
Netscape, Mosaic, etc.
E-mail discussions: http://www.ch.ic.ac.uk/hypermail/ectoc/
To unsubscribe from this list, send the message UNSUBSCRIBE ECTOC to
listserver@ic.ac.uk