This article covers the work being carried out to define a set of guidelines for Internet message bodies for files containing chemical related data. An Internet Draft was written and made available for comment and a discussion group initiated. Problems have arisen following discussions with the computer scientists comprising the "Internet Engineering Task Force" (IETF) who, although being the "de-facto" standards body for the Internet, did not feel themselves competent to assess the Draft. In order to make progress with this concept a IUPAC working party, chaired by Dr Henry Rzepa, has been set up to carry out an assessment of this work and report to the new IUPAC Committee on Printed and Electronic Publishing. Once the draft is accepted and published under the IUPAC banner it is hoped that the IETF will ratify the newly defined mail content "chemical".
Any software package accessing data from the "Information Super-Highway" must understand a set of basic rules regarding the storage and transmittal of data. These rules are laid down in documents known as RFCs (strangelyRequest for Comment!). RFC 1521 covers the so-called Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions or MIME types for short. This RFC standardises the use of specific file extensions which can expected to be found on the Internet and effectively reserves the use of these extensions for files of a particular data content. Anyone familiar with accessing the Internet with World Wide Web packages will have some experience of receiving HTML (Hyper Text Markup Language) documents. These consist of embedded codes which are interpreted by a web browser software package. Files of this type should carry the extension .HTM or .HTML. The coding should be invisible to the typical user but the information is vital to people responsible for writing the software packages and implementing these standards or to people having to plan for future oriented data storage, archival and retrieval.
Unfortunately, the original RFC 1521 is limited in the type of data it regards as being of interest to the users of the Internet. If you wish to make data content available as formatted text, or pictures, audio or video media types you are well catered for by RFC 1521 but chemical specific information must currently be forced into one of these definitions. An example would be a chemical structure with associated NMR and infrared spectral data. All three data sets would have to be transmitted as pictures if current MIME protocol was to be observed.
In February 1994 the original suggestion for an Internet primary chemical media type was suggested on the Computational Chemistry discussion list (CCL) and to chemistry and biology newsgroups. Using the input from these and other sources attempts have been underway to define a set of rules to ease the handling of scientific chemical related data over the Internet. A team consisting of Henry Rzepa at Imperial College London, Peter Murray-Rust at Glaxo in Stevenage and Ben Whitaker of Leeds University strayed into the realm of the computer scientists and deigned to write an Internet Draft defining a so-called "Chemical Primary Content Type" for MIME. This would extend the allowed primary contents from purely IMAGE, AUDIO, VIDEO etc, to include CHEMICAL. The need for the new content-type is the belief that people handling chemical data have requirements from the data received well beyond just observing the data. An example for the use expected from received data would be an infrared spectroscopist converting his data from %Transmission into Absorbance then rescaling to the wavenumber range of interest to them before further processing such as database searching. An NMR spectroscopist may wish to re-phase the data to his own standards before further processing.
In the chemical community we already have one major advantage over Internet users from other fields in that we have for many years been developing and implementing standard formats for data transmittal, storage and retrieval. We have access to large data archives, and already use many "de-facto" standards for digital data transmission in our field.
A list of the proposed chemical sub-type names is shown below. This list is not supposed to be the total of all possible sub-types but to concentrate on a small number of existing formats across the field of chemical information. To qualify for inclusion the format should be well defined in the scientific literature and in wide use.
|Primary/sub-type||Suggested file extension|
In July 1995 the authors of the draft met in Stockholm with the IETF committee and after over two hours of discussion it was concluded with the IETF expressing two major concerns. One worry was that if the chemistry community were to be allowed to define their own primary data content then the committee would be overwhelmed by requests from other specialised user communities with their own definitions. The second problem which they foresaw, probably correctly, was their own inability to assess the proposal due to a lack of specialist knowledge in the field of chemical information.
The answer to their first problem is probably purely organisational and should be well within the resources of the IETF to solve. A solution for the second worry has been found by going to the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemists (IUPAC). The original work had already been presented to the CCDB database committee in December 1994 and so the logical choice was to return to this committee when seeking an internationally renowned standards body in chemistry to validate the proposal.
As of August 1995 the IUPAC database committee will join with the Publications Committee to form a new Committee on Printed and Electronic Publishing (CPEP). Two new working parties are to be formed reporting to the CPEPone will continue the work of the Joint Committee on Atomic and Molecular Physical DataData Exchange, and the second headed by Henry Rzepa will work on Chemical MIME and produce a paper in the style of Pure and Applied Chemistry for the inaugural meeting of CPEP.
Henry Rzepa and the team now plan to produce a IUPAC Draft for the inaugural meeting of the CPEP in August. Anyone interested in contributing to this development can join the discussions on the chemical MIME initiative by sending an e-mail to email@example.com with the one line message: subscribe chemime yourname. The discussions can be viewed on the Web at
and the latest copies of the relevant Internet Drafts and RFCs can be obtained from
© Spectroscopy Europe 1996
This document was original published in the Tony Davies Column in Spectroscopy Europe Vol. 8 No. 1 (1996), and remains copyright Spectroscopy Europe. It may not be reproduced elsewhere, in print, electronically or in any other medium without the prior permission in writing of the Publishers, Spectroscopy Europe, 6 Charlton Mill, Charlton, Chichester, West Sussex PO18 0HY, UK, tel: (+44) 01243-811334, fax: (+44) 01243-811711, e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Spectroscopy Europe is a controlled circulation journal, available free-of-charge to qualifying readers in Europe. To request a free subscription e-mail email@example.com or visit our on-line registration service at Interlab.